Tuesday, April 14, 2009
The ugly secret of Pentagon 9/11
The ugly secret of Pentagon 9/11.....
A film by Paul Cross
9/11 films have become a genre, whether non-fiction or fictionalized
accounts of the events and truth of that awful day. This latest, Severe
Visibility, by actor, writer, director Paul Cross, is a riveting,
Kafkaesque film which takes places largely in the matrix of the
Pentagon, the belly of the beast on 9/11 and its aftermath. The small
cast and independent production reminds me somewhat of The Reflecting
Pool, with its relentless questioning of the official story.
In this case, the hero or anti-hero is U.S. Army Major Stanley Kruter,
who works in the ill-fated Pentagon accounting office, most of which was
obliterated along with Naval Intelligence that day, both keepers of many
lost secrets. Kruter is a Vietnam veteran winding down his military
career far from the bloody battlefields he experienced as a young man,
though they have left him troubled and suffering with bouts of
depression and anti-depressants.
Kruter, though mild-mannered, self-effacing, is a fiercely patriotic
man, somewhat at conflict with his inner peacenik for his military
career. To ease his psychic pain, he keeps a diary. His pen pal or
conscience to whom he writes and questions is no less than Thomas
Jefferson, whose determined visage graces a wall of Kruter’s small office.
It is in this room in hell on the morning of 9/11 that Kruter notices
his small TV’s reception is fluttering. As he brings the antennae cord
to the window’s metal frame, he sees a craft descending like a
lightening bolt towards the building. Just then, a friend bursts in the
doorway to ask him if he’s seen what’s happened in New York. Before he
can answer, the craft makes explosive contact with the building.
Full of self-doubt, even remorse, Kruter wonders if he saw what he
thinks he saw: not the 757 he’s told later hit the building, but a
smaller, slender, missile-like craft zooming down ground level at nearly
500 mph. Though he survives the explosion with only a nasty forehead
bruise, he is further damaged psychologically by the unthinkable truth
of what he feels he really saw. Could it possibly be? Could a soldier, a
lifer, a patriot like him even think such thoughts?
In fact, at a deposition in the Pentagon, when asked what he saw by
military brass and two FBI men, he has trouble, internal trouble,
spitting out 757. Under repeated questioning, he hesitantly clings to
the official story, afraid to even touch his original perception lest he
be thought a traitor. Of course, once he has testified that yes it was a
757, the die is cast. Whatever inner peace he had is destroyed by his
To make matters worse, as he leaves the building he is questioned by a
foreign journalist who challenges him when he repeats it was a 757. This
only pours fuel on Kruter’s internal rage. And we are off and running
through his world, suddenly gone dark, and haunted by his deepest fears,
not to mention the relentless reporter, military inquirers, the incoming
information from eyewitness reports on his car radio and home television
that rebut the 757 perception.
Sufficeth to say, Kruter’s crisis of conscience is full-blown. And even
the title, Severe Visibility, begins to sound awfully like, Severe
Disability, a perhaps fatal case of PTSD. It is an irony and reckoning
for this veteran soldier who thought he had distanced himself in the
fortress of patriotism from the suffering and violence of the
battlefield. Or are they both sides of a coin fate flipped for him? And
the call, at all costs, is his.
Within this taut set-up, we have a graceful dramatic device for
exposition of all the facts and non-facts and what questions arose after
Pentagon 9/11. They are doled out by the relentless reporter, whom
Kruter contacts, and by Kruter himself who begins to look more closely
at photos of the front of the building, and to realize the absence of
the massive wings, tail, fuselage, engines and baggage.
Kruter also notices a file cabinet and computer screen in an exposed
office on the second floor above where the airliner was said to hit.
They survived the heat that purportedly evaporated the craft and bodies.
As he pursues the impulses of his doubt, he awakens the suspicions of
others. A military guard catches Kruter entering a cordoned off office
directly below his own. He explains to the guard he wanted to see if the
view was any different than his. It wasn’t, but the guard reports him.
The revelations that the Pentagon hit was what he really saw begin to
tighten like a hanging noose around his neck, suffocating him. He visits
his psychiatrist, begins to rely on pills and whiskey to dim his
consciousness, but it’s too late. He is approached by the two FBI men
who had been at his original deposition and is questioned again. He
realizes that his worst nightmare is beginning to come true.
I leave the rest and the best of it all for you to see -- you being
anyone who likes a good story well told, or who are interested in what
really happened at the Pentagon on 9/11. Ultimately, what Kruter finds
out catapults him into this matrix of intrigue, madness, and suspense,
setting him on a collision course with his destiny, one from which he
finds no return.
Severe Visibility was an Official Selection of the New York
International Independent Film and Video Festival of 2007.